> For the complete documentation index, see [llms.txt](https://faction-os.gitbook.io/faction-os-docs/llms.txt). Markdown versions of documentation pages are available by appending `.md` to page URLs; this page is available as [Markdown](https://faction-os.gitbook.io/faction-os-docs/.spec_system/archive/sessions/phase20-session11-release-evidence-and-event-privacy/validation.md). # Validation Report **Session ID**: `phase20-session11-release-evidence-and-event-privacy` **Package**: cross-cutting (`package: null`) **Validated**: 2026-06-29 **Result**: PASS ## Validation Summary | Check | Status | Notes | | ------------------------- | ------ | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | Code Review | PASS | `code-review.md` exists with `Result: RESOLVED` and all-uncommitted-changes scope. | | Tasks Complete | PASS | 25/25 tasks complete. | | Files Exist | PASS | 24/24 spec deliverables exist and are non-empty. | | ASCII Encoding | PASS | `file`, non-ASCII scan, and CRLF scan passed for all deliverables. | | Tests Passing | PASS | Required typechecks, full Vitest, and app-desktop Playwright e2e passed after one validation repair. | | Database/Schema Alignment | N/A | No DB layer is configured and no migration/schema/database files changed. | | Quality Gates | PASS | Package typechecks, `npm test`, e2e, `git diff --check`, format, and lint passed. | | Conventions | PASS | Biome format/lint and targeted inspection found no obvious naming, structure, error-handling, comment, testing, or DB convention violations. | | Security & GDPR | PASS | No findings; see `security-compliance.md`. | | Behavioral Quality | PASS | Spot-check covered trust boundaries, mutation/idempotency, failure paths, contract alignment, and redaction. | | UI Product Surface | PASS | Web tests and e2e assert product-facing labels and absence of raw/debug execution detail on normal surfaces. | **Overall**: PASS ## Evidence Ledger | Check | Command or Inspection | Result | Evidence / Blocker | | ------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------ | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | Project state | `bash /home/aiwithapex/.codex/plugins/cache/apex-spec-system/apex-spec/2.1.3-codex/skills/apex-spec/scripts/analyze-project.sh --json` | PASS | Current session is `phase20-session11-release-evidence-and-event-privacy`; monorepo true; package null/cross-cutting; session dir exists. | | Code review | \`rg -n "^\\*\Result\\\\*: | ^\\*\Scope\\\\*: | all uncommitted | | Task completion | `rg -n "\\[ \\]" .spec_system/specs/phase20-session11-release-evidence-and-event-privacy/tasks.md` plus checklist inspection | PASS | Only legend contains `[ ]`; progress summary says 25/25 tasks complete. | | Deliverables | `test -s <24 deliverable files>` | PASS | All 24 deliverables from `spec.md` exist and are non-empty. | | ASCII/LF | `file <24 deliverables>`; `LC_ALL=C rg --pcre2 -n "[^\\x00-\\x7F]" <24 deliverables>`; `rg -n $'\\r' <24 deliverables>` | PASS | All deliverables are ASCII text/JavaScript source; no non-ASCII or CRLF matches. | | Protocol typecheck | `source "$HOME/.nvm/nvm.sh" && nvm use 26.2.0 >/dev/null && npm --workspace packages/protocol run typecheck` | PASS | `@factionos/protocol` `tsc --noEmit` exited 0. | | Server typecheck | `source "$HOME/.nvm/nvm.sh" && nvm use 26.2.0 >/dev/null && npm --workspace apps/server run typecheck` | PASS | `@factionos/server` `tsc --noEmit` exited 0 after validation repair. | | Web typecheck | `source "$HOME/.nvm/nvm.sh" && nvm use 26.2.0 >/dev/null && npm --workspace apps/web run typecheck` | PASS | `@factionos/web` `tsc -b --noEmit` exited 0. | | Focused repair test | `source "$HOME/.nvm/nvm.sh" && nvm use 26.2.0 >/dev/null && npx vitest run apps/server/tests/fileMutationManager.test.ts` | PASS | 1 test file passed; 6 tests passed after replacing positional rollback execution selection with a rollback-field selector. | | Full tests | `source "$HOME/.nvm/nvm.sh" && nvm use 26.2.0 >/dev/null && npm test` | PASS | 273 test files passed, 1 skipped; 3118 tests passed, 1 skipped. | | Browser e2e | `source "$HOME/.nvm/nvm.sh" && nvm use 26.2.0 >/dev/null && npm run test:e2e -- --project=app-desktop tests/e2e/orchestration-command-center.e2e.ts --reporter=line` | PASS | 8 app-desktop Playwright tests passed. | | Whitespace | `git diff --check` | PASS | No whitespace errors. | | Format | `source "$HOME/.nvm/nvm.sh" && nvm use 26.2.0 >/dev/null && npm run format:check` | PASS | 768 files checked; no fixes applied. | | Lint | `source "$HOME/.nvm/nvm.sh" && nvm use 26.2.0 >/dev/null && npm run lint` | PASS | 770 files checked; no fixes applied. | | Database/schema | \`git diff --name-only | rg '(^ | /)(migrations? | | Dependency/security | `git diff --name-only -- package.json package-lock.json apps/*/package.json packages/*/package.json public-demo/package.json public-website/package.json` | PASS | No dependency manifest changes. | | Secret/security | \`git diff -U0 | rg -n "AKIA\[0-9A-Z]{16} | BEGIN (RSA | | Success criteria | `spec.md` criteria inspection plus typecheck/test/e2e/docs evidence | PASS | Functional, testing, non-functional, and quality-gate criteria are satisfied by release ledger, docs, tests, typechecks, full tests, e2e, and hygiene commands. | | Conventions | `.spec_system/CONVENTIONS.md` inspection plus `npm run format:check`, `npm run lint`, typechecks, and test file inspection | PASS | No obvious convention violations in naming, structure, error handling, comments, testing, or DB conventions. | | Security/GDPR | `security-compliance.md` targeted checklist | PASS | No security or GDPR findings. | | Behavioral quality | `references/behavioral-quality-checklist.md` applied to `apps/server/tests/fileMutationManager.test.ts`, `apps/server/tests/commandCenterRoutes.test.ts`, `apps/web/tests/QueueWorkbench.test.tsx`, `apps/web/tests/wsClientPrivacy.test.ts`, `tests/e2e/orchestration-command-center.e2e.ts` | PASS | Spot-check found no high-severity violations; tests cover validation, idempotency, rollback, failure paths, contract alignment, and redaction. | | UI product surface | \`rg -n "debug | telemetry | seed | ## 1. Code Review Gate ### Status: PASS **Report**: `code-review.md` **Result**: RESOLVED **Issues**: None. The review report states its scope as all uncommitted changes in the working tree and lists 28 reviewed files. During validation, one test assertion in an already reviewed file was repaired and independently verified by focused test, server typecheck, full Vitest, e2e, format/lint, whitespace, ASCII, and LF checks. ## 2. Task Completion ### Status: PASS **Tasks**: 25/25 complete **Incomplete tasks**: None. ## 3. Deliverables Verification ### Status: PASS | File | Found | Status | | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----- | ------ | | `.spec_system/specs/phase20-session11-release-evidence-and-event-privacy/release-evidence.md` | Yes | PASS | | `packages/protocol/tests/orchestration.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `packages/protocol/tests/orchestrationCommandCenter.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `packages/protocol/README_protocol.md` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/server/tests/taskExecutionCoordinator.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/server/tests/taskExecutionCoordinator.container.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/server/tests/planCampaignExecutableDispatch.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/server/tests/planCampaignDagRecovery.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/server/tests/fileMutationManager.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/server/tests/managedAgentSessionManager.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/server/tests/channelCommandRoutes.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/server/tests/commandCenterRoutes.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/server/tests/exportRoute.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/web/tests/QueueWorkbench.test.tsx` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/web/tests/CampaignWorkbench.test.tsx` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/web/tests/FileGitWorkbench.test.tsx` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/web/tests/HeroLineageWorkbench.test.tsx` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/web/tests/ChannelCommandPanel.test.tsx` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/web/tests/wsClientPrivacy.test.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `tests/e2e/orchestration-command-center.e2e.ts` | Yes | PASS | | `docs/api/README_api.md` | Yes | PASS | | `apps/server/README_server.md` | Yes | PASS | | `docs/privacy-and-security.md` | Yes | PASS | | `docs/release.md` | Yes | PASS | **Missing deliverables**: None. ## 4. ASCII Encoding Check ### Status: PASS | File Set | Encoding | Line Endings | Status | | ----------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ------ | | 24 session deliverables | ASCII text or JavaScript source, ASCII text | LF | PASS | **Encoding issues**: None. ## 5. Test Results ### Status: PASS | Metric | Value | | ------------------- | ---------------------------------------- | | Protocol typecheck | PASS | | Server typecheck | PASS | | Web typecheck | PASS | | Focused repair test | 1 file passed; 6 tests passed | | Full Vitest files | 273 passed; 1 skipped | | Full Vitest tests | 3118 passed; 1 skipped | | Browser e2e | 8 passed | | Coverage | Not emitted by these configured commands | **Failed tests**: None after validation repair. **Fixes applied during validation**: * `apps/server/tests/fileMutationManager.test.ts`: replaced a positional `executions[1]` rollback assertion with a selector that finds the file execution whose attachment has `operation: "rollback"` and `rollbackState: "rolled_back"`. This fixed the full-suite failure where execution list ordering exposed the prior write run at index 1. ## 6. Database/Schema Alignment ### Status: N/A **Evidence**: `.spec_system/CONVENTIONS.md` says `Database | not configured`; `git diff --name-only | rg '(^|/)(migrations?|schema|prisma|drizzle|sequelize|knex|sql|database|db)(/|\\.|$)'` returned no changed DB/schema/migration artifacts. **Issues found**: None. ## 7. Success Criteria From `spec.md`: **Functional requirements**: * PASS - Terminal, Git, file mutation, container, and supported managed-agent control have release evidence or truthful unavailable evidence in `release-evidence.md`, server/web tests, and app-desktop e2e. * PASS - Campaign and queue states do not complete from metadata-only, proposal-only, preview-only, approved-not-executing, or unavailable work; verified by campaign, queue, protocol, and e2e tests. * PASS - Guarded actions execute only through proved executor families and return unavailable or approved-not-executing for non-ready families; covered by server tests, docs, and release ledger. * PASS - Template and channel intake remain local-approval and proposal-first until a local executable queue entry exists; covered by channel route/UI tests and e2e. * PASS - Release docs and UI labels use action verbs only for working actions; covered by docs updates, web tests, and e2e. **Testing requirements**: * PASS - Protocol tests cover blocked raw fields and compact command-center public event shapes. * PASS - Server tests cover queue, campaign, file, guarded, hero, container, channel, export, and diagnostics privacy semantics. * PASS - Web tests cover broad-row state labels, product-facing verbs, unavailable/retry copy, duplicate in-flight guards, and no raw execution detail. * PASS - Browser e2e covers the Command Center release evidence path in `tests/e2e/orchestration-command-center.e2e.ts`. * PASS - Release evidence matrix records command results and remaining unsupported paths. **Non-functional requirements**: * PASS - Broad rows, events, exports, diagnostics, examples, and docs block raw commands, outputs, diffs, file contents, patches, tokens, secrets, broad paths, provider payloads, and webhook bodies. * PASS - Optional runtime dependencies fail closed with unavailable states and recovery guidance. * PASS - Idempotency and duplicate-trigger prevention remain active in dispatch, approval, conversion, rollback, and lifecycle controls. * PASS - Hosted identity, trusted unified erasure, production-hosted validation, authorized Cloudflare deploy evidence, and legal/privacy approval remain no-claim. **Quality gates**: * PASS - All files ASCII-encoded and LF-only. * PASS - Code follows project conventions by spot-check and Biome checks. * PASS - Primary user-facing surfaces contain product-facing copy only. * PASS - `npm --workspace packages/protocol run typecheck`. * PASS - `npm --workspace apps/server run typecheck`. * PASS - `npm --workspace apps/web run typecheck`. * PASS - `npm test`. * PASS - `npm run test:e2e -- --project=app-desktop tests/e2e/orchestration-command-center.e2e.ts --reporter=line`. * PASS - `git diff --check`. ## 8. Conventions Compliance ### Status: PASS **Categories spot-checked**: naming, file structure, error handling, comments, testing, and database conventions. **Convention violations**: None. Evidence: * `.spec_system/CONVENTIONS.md` confirms npm workspaces, Biome, TypeScript typechecks, Vitest, Playwright, and no configured DB layer. * `npm run format:check` checked 768 files with no fixes. * `npm run lint` checked 770 files with no fixes. * Package typechecks and full tests passed. ## 9. Security & GDPR Compliance ### Status: PASS **Full report**: See `security-compliance.md` in this session directory. #### Summary | Area | Status | Findings | | -------- | ------ | -------- | | Security | PASS | 0 issues | | GDPR | PASS | 0 issues | **Critical violations**: None. ## 10. Behavioral Quality Spot-Check ### Status: PASS **Checklist applied**: Yes. **Files spot-checked**: * `apps/server/tests/fileMutationManager.test.ts` * `apps/server/tests/commandCenterRoutes.test.ts` * `apps/web/tests/QueueWorkbench.test.tsx` * `apps/web/tests/wsClientPrivacy.test.ts` * `tests/e2e/orchestration-command-center.e2e.ts` **Categories spot-checked**: trust boundaries, resource cleanup, mutation safety, failure paths, contract alignment, and error information boundaries. **Violations found**: None. **Fixes applied during validation**: * `apps/server/tests/fileMutationManager.test.ts`: made rollback evidence assertion independent of execution list ordering. ## 11. UI Product-Surface Spot-Check ### Status: PASS **Surfaces inspected**: Queue Workbench, Campaign Workbench, File/Git Workbench, Hero Lineage Workbench, Channel Command Panel, WebSocket normalization, and app-desktop Command Center e2e. **Diagnostics found in primary UI**: None. Product surfaces assert unavailable/retry/action labels and reject raw command text, stdout/stderr, diffs, file content, Docker output, workspace paths, provider payloads, and secret tokens. **Allowed debug/admin surfaces**: None added by this session. **Fixes applied during validation**: None. ## Validation Result ### PASS Session `phase20-session11-release-evidence-and-event-privacy` passes validation. One full-suite test failure was found and fixed during validation, then revalidated with focused Vitest, server typecheck, full Vitest, app-desktop Playwright e2e, format, lint, whitespace, ASCII, and LF checks. ### Unresolved Failures And Blockers None. ## Next Steps Next command: `updateprd` --- # Agent Instructions This documentation is published with GitBook. GitBook is the documentation platform designed so that both humans and AI agents can read, navigate, and reason over technical content effectively. Learn more at gitbook.com. ## Querying This Documentation If you need additional information that is not directly available in this page, you can query the documentation dynamically by asking a question. Perform an HTTP GET request on the current page URL with the `ask` query parameter, and the optional `goal` query parameter: ``` GET https://faction-os.gitbook.io/faction-os-docs/.spec_system/archive/sessions/phase20-session11-release-evidence-and-event-privacy/validation.md?ask=&goal= ``` `ask` is the immediate question: it should be specific, self-contained, and written in natural language. `goal` is optional and describes the broader end goal you are ultimately trying to accomplish on behalf of the user. GitBook uses it to tailor the answer towards what is most useful for that goal. The response will contain a direct answer to the question and relevant excerpts and sources from the documentation. Use this mechanism when the answer is not explicitly present in the current page, you need clarification or additional context, or you want to retrieve related documentation sections.